5 / 23

What are today's flavors?

  • Whiskey’s Bonnet
  • Fudge Jo Brown
  • Rhubarb Ginger
  • Perfect Couple (PB)
  • Green Tea w/chocolate
  • Key Lime
  • Cookie Butter Hazelnut
  • Mexican Hot Chocolate
  • Lemon Blueberry
  • Hazelnut Brownie
  • Chocolate Chip Fasciana
  • Cherry Amaretto
  • Peanut Butter Cookie
  • Salted Caramel Brownie
  • Strawberry
  • Hamilton Creme Pie
  • Miso Maple Pecan
  • Brown Sugar Cinnamon
  • Pineapple Guava
  • Blueberry Maple
  • Black Irish Stout
  • Caramel Toffee
  • Bavarian Creme
  • S’moreo


**    SHOP HOURS  are Wednesday-Saturday Noon-8pm or sellout  **

  * limit 5 customers in the shop at a time

  * limit 12 slices per customer

   ** we do not accept any orders

Welcome to Cheesecake Machismo, New York’s finest and most unique cheesecake selection.  Come visit the land of cheesecake on a voyage of delectable, one-of-a-kind cheesecake flavors. Stop by for a slice or two or buy one of our well-known Frankencakes where you can select any combination of flavors that are in stock of 6 – 12 slices. Frankencakes are STRICTLY walk in only, FIRST COME FIRST SERVED and are limit 12 slices total per customer. We do often sell out before closing time. We are open Weds, Thurs, Fri, & Sat noon-8pm or until we sellout, and are closed Sunday – Tuesday.  Please call to see if we have sold out for the day.  Please click where it says “WHAT ARE TODAY’S FLAVORS?” to see what we have for the day.