7 / 18

What are today's flavors?

  • Hazelnut Brownie
  • Butter Rum Apple
  • Caramel Toffee
  • Strawberry
  • Blueberry Maple
  • Chocolate Chip Fasciana
  • Peanut Butter Cookie
  • Cherry Amaretto
  • Bavarian Creme
  • Tiger Stripes
  • Toasted Almond Hazelnut
  • Jo Brown
  • Chocolate Cabernet


Welcome to Cheesecake Machismo, New York’s finest and most unique cheesecake selection.  Come visit the land of cheesecake on a voyage of delectable, one-of-a-kind cheesecake flavors. Stop by for a slice or two, order a whole cheesecake (orders always require at least a minimum of 7 days notice and are limit 2 to an order, *we are currently booked until mid-July 2019*), or buy one of our well-known Frankencakes where you can select any combination of flavors that are in stock to make up 1 cake of 12 slices. Frankencakes are STRICTLY walk in only, FIRST COME FIRST SERVED and are limit 2 per customer. We do often sell out before closing time. We are open Tues- Fri noon-8pm or until we sellout, Sat noon-6pm or until we sellout, and are always closed Sunday and Monday. Please call to see if we have sold out for the day.  Please click where it says “WHAT ARE TODAY’S FLAVORS?” to see what we have for the day.